|
History
of Nichiren Shu Buddhism
by Rev. Ryuei Michael McCormick
The Mission to Kyoto
Nichizo (1269-1342) was the
half-brother of Nichiro, and he became Nichiro's disciple in 1275.
On his deathbed, Nichiren Shonin commissioned Nichizo with the task
of converting the emperor in Kyoto to the Wonderful Dharma of the
Lotus Flower Teaching. From November 1, 1293 until February 10,
1294 he chanted the Jigage 100 times every night at Yuigahama Beach.
This was the inspiration for the practice of Aragyo which occurs
annually at Nakayama Hokekyoji. After completing these prayers and
a pilgrimage to the important places in Nichiren's life, Nichizo
finally arrived in Kyoto on April 1, 1294. Due to pressure from
the Tendai sect, Nichizo was exiled in 1307, 1310, and in 1321.
None of these exiles were very severe. The first exile lasted two
years, but Nichizo spent them in the suburbs of Kyoto. Nichizo was
quickly pardoned from the other two exiles. After the third exile,
the Emperor Godaigo permitted the propagation of Odaimoku and Nichizo
was allowed to found the Myokenji Temple. In the following years,
the Emperor Godaigo and his son Prince Morinaga intrigued to overthrow
the shogunate and restore the imperial family to power. In 1333,
Myokenji Temple joined in the pray for Emperor Godaigo's success.
Fortunately for Nichizo, the emperor was successful and the Kamakuran
Shogunate fell in 1333. In 1334, the emperor recognized Myokenji
Temple as an Imperial Prayer Temple. In this way, Nichiren Buddhism
was finally given official recognition. Nichizo's lineage would
later be known as the Shijo Lineage due to the location of Myokenji
Temple in Kyoto. The Myokenji Temple was burned down by Tendai sohei
(soldier-monks) from Mt. Hiei in 1387. It was rebuilt in 1398 and
renamed Myohonji. It took the name Myokenji again in 1519.
Daigaku Myojitsu (1297-1364)
carried on Nichizo's work. In fact, Daigaku may have been instrumental
in winning the favor of the Imperial Court since he was a member
of the Konoye family which was a noble family with close connections
to the court. In 1358, Daigaku was asked to pray for rain during
a drought. His prayers were so successful that he was given the
title Chief Abbot (Daisojo) of the Nichiren Sect by the emperor.
In addition, the emperor officially recognized Nichiren Shonin as
a great bodhisattva, and Nichiro and Nichizo as bodhisattvas. In
addition, Daigaku began missionary work in Osaka, Okayama.
Nichizon (1265-1345) was
a disciple of Nikko, who travelled to Kyoto with Nichimoku and Nichigo
who were also Nikko's disciples. Unfortunately, Nichimoku died on
the way and Nichigo returned to Fuji with his ashes. Nichizon alone
went on to Kyoto. In 1339, he established the Jogyo-in Temple. The
Jogyo-in was later renamed Yoboji Temple.
Nichijo (1298-1369) was a
disciple of Nichiin, one of the Nine Senior Disciples of Nichiro.
Both Nichiin (1264-1328) and Nichijo were known for teaching that
the essential section of the Lotus Sutra is superior to the theoretical
sections, a doctrine known as shoretsu. He was also the uncle of
Ashikaga Takauji, the first Ashikaga shogun. Ashikaga Takauji became
the shogun in 1336 when he chased Emperor Godaigo out of Kyoto and
enthroned Emperor Komyo instead. Nichijo came to Kyoto in 1341 and
founded the Honkokuji Temple there in 1345 under the patronage of
his nephew, the new shogun Ashikaga Takauji. Nichijo's lineage is
known as the Rokujo Lineage because that is the name of the location
of Honkokuji Temple in Kyoto.
By the early 15th century
many monks split from the earlier Kyoto temples such as Myokenji
and Honkokuji. They objected to the compromises made by the earlier
temples with the aristocracy and the shogunate. They hoped to restore
the purity of Nichiren Buddhism and they also emphasized the shoretsu
doctrine. "Shoretsu" is a term that refers to the doctrine
of the superiority of the essential section of the Lotus Sutra over
the theoretical section of the sutra. Rather than relying on their
own insights or innovations, the Nichiren Buddhist monks strove
to prove their orthodoxy by appealing to the authority of the Lotus
Sutra and the writings of Nichiren Shonin. They also refused to
compromise with others in order to maintain their doctrinal integrity.
Many of them ended up founding lineages which still exist today
as minor schools of Nichiren Buddhism. Nichijitsu, Nichijo, Nichiju,
Nichijin, Nichiryu, and Nisshin were among the most notable of those
who split from the earlier Kyoto temples.
Nichijitsu (1318-1378) and
Nichijo (d.1415) were two brothers who left Myokenji Temple after
the death of Daigaku Myojitsu's successor Rogen. Together they founded
the Myokakuji Temple in Kyoto in 1378. In 1413, Nichijo set forth
a series of regulations that forbid giving services to or receiving
donations from slanderers of the Dharma. This was the beginning
of fuju fuse (no giving and no receiving). This was in reaction
to what he felt was the overly conciliatory policies of Myokenji
Temple.
The
Kyoto Lineages
Nichiju (1314-1392) was originally
a Tendai monk who learned about Nichiren Buddhism from Nichiin,
a monk connected with Taisekiji Temple. In 1379 he read the Kaimoku
Sho and the Nyosetsu Shugyo Sho and was so impressed that he converted
to Nichiren Buddhism. Because Nichiin had already passed away at
the time of his conversion, he went to study with Nisshu of Guboji
Temple in Mama. Nichijo was even appointed the head of the school
there by Nisshu. Later, Nichiju visted Nisson, the Chief Priest
of Hommyoji Temple in Nakayama and later went to Kyoto as Nisson's
deputy to convert the emperor in 1381. He was well received but
unable to convert the emperor, so he went again as Nisson's deputy
in 1382. He travelled to Kyoto a third time in 1383 and stayed.
On that third occasion he was not acting as Nisson's deputy and
there seems to have been a break in their relations. In 1388, after
Nisshu passed away, Nichiju declared that he had inherited the Dharma
directly from the scrolls of the Lotus Sutra and the teachings of
Nichiren. Nichiju followed the shoretsu doctrine. In fact, he taught
that only the 16th chapter contained the true teaching. He founded
the Myomanji Temple in Kyoto in 1385. It is now the head temple
of the Kempon Hokke Shu (founding date 1384).
Nichijin (1339-1419) was
a disicple of Nichijo of Honkokuji in Kyoto. He became the head
priest of Honjoji Temple in 1369. In 1397 he began to preach the
shoretsu doctrine and opposed the Honkokuji Temple which was preaching
the doctrine of the unity (itchi in Japanese) of the essential and
theoretical sections of the Lotus Sutra. The Honjoji Temple would
become the head temple of what is now called the Hokke Shu Jin-Monryu
(founding date 1406).
Nichiryu (1385-1464) was
originally a disciple of the Chief Priest Nissei at Myohonji Temple
(the rebuilt Myokenji Temple). When Nissei died in 1405 the monk
Gatsumyo took over. Nichiryu did not approve of Gatsumyo's lax ways
and even bested him in a debate. Gatsumyo then forced Nichiryu and
his faction out of the temple. Nichiryu then established new temples
and taught the doctrine of shoretsu, emphasizing that the true teaching
is found only in chapters 15-22 of the Lotus Sutra. For this reason,
the school he founded was called the Eight Chapter School (Happon-ha).
The Honnoji Temple in Kyoto which Nichiryu founded is now the head
temple of the Honmon Hokke Shu (founding date 1423)
.
Nisshin (1407-1488) of the Nakayama lineage came to be known as
the "Pot Wearing Saint" because of the tortures he endured
at the hands of Shogun Yoshinori. In 1439 he attempted to convert
the Shogun Ashikaga Yoshinori. As Nisshin was writing his own version
of the Rissho Anokoku-ron, he was arrested. For two years he was
tortured in prison in an effort to force him to renounce the Odaimoku.
On one occasion, it is said that a red-hot iron kettle was jammed
on his head. This is known as the Takehara Persecution. In the end,
Nisshin was released when Ashikaga Yoshinori was assassinated. Nisshin
is credited with founding thirty temples, memorializing high officials
on eight occasions, and winning sixty religious debates. Nisshin
exemplified the spirit of shakubuku (to break and subdue false views)and
fuju fuse even at the risk of his own life and in the face of terrible
suffering.
Priests like Nisshin were
not the only ones willing to offer their lives for the Lotus Sutra
nor were the persectutions confined to Kyoto. In 1436 the Nichiren
priests Nisshin (not the "Pot Wearer") and Nichimyo publicly
debated a Tendai priest named Shinkai in Kamakura. Ashikaga Mochiuji,
the governor of Kamakura, was so incensed that he destroyed all
the Nichiren Buddhist temples in the city, exiled the priests, confiscated
the lands of any samurai practicing Nichiren Buddhism, and threatened
to execute any commoner who did not renounce the Odaimoku. He relented,
however, when 60 people volunteered to be executed rather than give
up practicing the Odaimoku. This event is known as the Eikyo Persection.
The
Machishu Culture & the Hokke Ikki
After Nisshin, the various Nichiren Buddhist lineages within Kyoto
struggled with each other. Each faction claimed that it alone truly
upheld Nichiren Shonin's teachings. Many of these factions took
up the practice of fuju fuse and vigorous shakubuku. In 1451, for
instance, Myomanji Temple created a set of regulations even stricter
than those set forth by Nichijo of Myokakuji Temple back in 1413.
Eventually, the various Nichiren Buddhist temples realized that
they would need to set aside their conflicts in order to present
a united front against the forces of the warrior monks of Mt. Hiei
which threatened them. This resulted in the Kansho Accord of 1466.
The Kansho Accord contained six principles on which all the temples
of Kyoto agreed, with the exception of Honpoji Temple of Nisshin's
lineage. The six principles were:
1. The identity of the theoretical
and essential sections of the Lotus Sutra, though one or the other
may be considered superior depending on people's capacities and
level of understanding. This principle attempted to reconcile the
shoretsu (superiority of the essential section) and itchi (harmony
of both sections) doctrines.
2. All Nichiren Buddhists, both monastic and lay, should practice
shakubuku.
3. Nichiren Buddhists are prohibited from making pilgrimages to
the temples or shrines of slanderers.
4. Nichiren Buddhists are not to receive offerings from slanderers,
unless those offerings are made for secular reasons.
5. Though shakubuku (the way of subduing slander) and shoju (the
way of embracing what is true) are both ways to teach the Dharma,
shakubuku is now the proper one to use. This is a reiteration of
point two.
6. Lay followers should not forsake their original teachers, though
they may give offerings to more than one temple if those temples
all agree to it.
The Kansho Accord did not
last for very long. The Onin War of 1467-1477 was particularly destructive,
and in 1469 the Tendai warrior-monks burned down much of the aristocratic
northern part of Kyoto. The Nichiren temples were in the southern
part of the city, so they became rallying points for the merchants
who lived there. The townspeople (machishu) formed their own militias
to protect themselves from the warrior-monks of Mt. Hiei, peasant
rebellions, and warlords from the provinces. Since many of them
were Nichiren Buddhists, the temples became virtual fortresses.
At this point, the temples resumed their struggle for power.
Nisshin (1444-1528) was a
monk who studied at Myohonji Temple (the former Myokenji Temple).
He was an adherent of shoretsu, and in particular he emphasized
the superiority of the 16th chapter. Eventually he left Myohonji
and founded Honryuji Temple in Kyoto in 1489. The Honryuji Temple
is now the head temple of the Hokke Shu Shin-Monryu (founded 1488).
With the creation of a new sect by Nisshin, the Kansho Accord was
shown to be totally ineffective in ending sectarianism.
Despite the power struggles
and doctrinal conflicts, the Kyoto temple militias gained in strength
as the Ashikaga Shogunate's power waned and Japan descended into
anarchy. When the Nembutsu based peasant rebellions threatened the
city of Kyoto in the summer of 1532, the militias came out in force
to defend the city, and for the next four years they ruled the city
of Kyoto. This brief rule of the Nichiren Buddhist townspeople is
known as the Lotus Uprising (Hokke Ikki) in contrast to the Pure
Land Buddhist peasant rebellions known as the Single-minded [Faith
in Nembutsu] Uprisings (Ikko Ikki).
The Lotus Uprising ended disastrously in 1536 when a Nichiren Buddhist
lay follower challenged and then defeated a Tendai monk in a public
debate. Incensed, the warrior-monks of Mt. Hiei descended upon the
city in force and burned down all 21 of the Nichiren Buddhist head
temples in Kyoto as well as the whole southern half of the city
and a good portion of the northern half. This event is known as
the Tenmon Persecution.
After the Tenmon Persecution,
many of the Nichiren Buddhist clergy and lay followers took refuge
in Sakai near Osaka. In 1542 they were finally allowed to return
to Kyoto. By 1545, 15 head temples had been reestablished. Once
again, the temples were forced to put an end to sectarianism in
order to present a unified front against Mt. Hiei and their other
enemies. In 1564 the 15 temples signed the Eiroku Accord in which
they attempted to reconcile the shoretsu and itchi factions of Nichiren
Buddhism. This agreement was extended by the Tensho Accord of 1575.
In spite of their new found unity, and the razing of Mt. Hiei by
the dictator Oda Nobunaga in 1571, the Nichiren Buddhist temples
of Kyoto would never regain the power and prestige they had attained
at the height of the Lotus Uprising.
Oda Nobunaga's destruction
of Mt. Hiei was not done as a favor to the Nichiren Buddhists of
Kyoto. In fact, Nobunaga was determined to bring all of the Buddhist
schools under his firm control. In 1579, he decided to teach the
Nichiren Buddhists a lesson they would not soon forget. In that
year he demanded that a debate be held in Azuchi Castle between
representatives of Nichiren Buddhism and Pure Land Buddhism. Despite
the superior arguments of the Nichiren Buddhist monks, Nobunaga
declared the Pure Land monks the winners and condemned the three
main Nichiren Buddhist representatives to death. He then demanded
that the Nichiren Buddhists pay reparations to the Pure Land school,
sign an admission of defeat, and cease all proselytizing in Kyoto.
This is known as the Azuchi Persecution. After the Azuchi Debate,
the major schools of Nichiren Buddhism emphasized the shoju method
of propagation rather than the shakubuku method.
The
Fuju Fuse Debate
Nichio (1565-1630) was the
leading figure in the last important development of Nichiren Buddhism
in the fuedal era. In 1595, the dictator Hideyoshi requested that
100 representatives from each of the major Buddhist schools attend
monthly memorial services for his ancestors before the Great Buddha
that he had commissioned. The leaders of the Kyoto temples believed
that to refuse would mean the destruction of their temples and communities.
In addition, while they agreed in principle that one should not
give services for slanderers or receive donations from them (the
fuju fuse doctrine), they argued that the secular authorities were
exceptions to this rule. Only Nichio, the head priest of Myokakuji
Temple refused to compromise. In protest, he left Myokakuji Temple.
In 1599, Tokugawa Ieyasu, at that time one of the five regents appointed
to lead the country after Hideyoshi's death, invited Nichio to debate
his views with the leaders of the Kyoto temples at Osaka Castle.
The outcome was foreordained by Tokugawa Ieyasu, and Nichio was
sent into exile to Tsushima Island the next year.
In 1608, a new blow was dealt
to Nichiren Buddhism by Tokugawa Ieyasu who was now the new shogun.
In that year, Nikkyo, the chief priest of Myomanji Temple, was invited
to the Tokugawa Castle in the new capital of Edo to debate Shakudo
of the Pure Land school. The night before the debates, intruders
broke into Nikkyo's quarters and beat him so badly that he was unable
to debate the next day even though the Tokugawa Ieyasu ordered him
carried in on a stretcher. The Shogun declared Shakudo the winner
by default and sentenced Nikkyo and five of his followers to have
their noses and ears removed.
Tokugawa Ieyasu also demanded that the Nichiren Buddhists cease
their propagation efforts. Nichion, head priest of Kuonji Temple
at Mount Minobu refused to go along with that order and he was arrested
and sentenced to crucifixion. Fortunately for him, one of the Shogun's
concubines, the Lady Oman, threatened to kill herself in front of
her children if Nichion was executed. The Shogun relented and Nichion
was released, though he did not return to Kuonji Temple for fear
of not being able to propagate Nichiren Buddhism if he should resume
his position as chief priest. This event is called the Keicho Persecution,
after the era in which it occured.
Nichio was finally pardoned
in 1616 and allowed to return to Myokakuji Temple. By this time,
those who supported the fuju fuse stance had become quite numerous.
In 1623, the fuju fuse movement was even officially permitted by
the shogunate. Such permission, however, was subject to the convenience
of the Tokugawas. The debate about whether to attend a government
sponsored memorial service came up again in 1626 when the wife of
Shogun Hidetada died. Two factions arose. The Minbou led faction
decided to attend the ceremony, whereas the Ikegami led faction
decided not to attend. Naturally, Nichio was on the Ikegami side
of the debates which followed. In 1630 the Tokugawa Shogunate sponsored
a debate between the two factions and subsequently declared the
more accomodating Minobu faction the winners. Nichio was sentenced
to another exile, but he had already died. With the debate of 1630,
fuju fuse was forbidden by the Tokugawa Shogunate.
In 1665, the Tokugawa Shogunate ruled that all temples would have
to report the land which had been granted to them by the government
for worship. This meant that all the temples had to admit that they
had received their land as a donation from the government for religious
purposes. Those who still clung to the fuju fuse doctrine could
not do this without compromising their principles, and so the new
rule effectively ended the fuju fuse movement. They could no longer
receive any recognition from the government, and without that recognition
they could not operate their temples. Without membership in a government
recognized temple the fuju fuse adherents became outlaws. The fuju
fuse movement would remain illegal until 1876. The movement is now
called the Nichiren Shu Fuju Fuse-Ha (founding date 1595).
The
Modern Reformers
Udana-in Nichiki (1800-1859)
was a great scholar and reformer of Nichiren Buddhism who helped
to establish the modern education system of the Nichiren Shu. He
also taught that the present age demands the practice of shoju rather
than shakubuku. He argued that the Rissho Ankoku Ron was no longer
applicable to the times and that a new method of propagation would
need to be used in a time when religious debate was no longer a
convincing or effective means of converting others.
Nagamatsu Seifu Nissen (1817-1890) was originally a priest of the
Honmon Hokke Shu, but he left that school due to his disgust with
the corruption of the clergy. In 1857, he founded the Butsuryu-Ko
in Kyoto. This became the Honmon Butsuryu Shu.
In 1868 the Tokugawa Shogunate
fell and the Meiji emperor was restored to power in the Meiji Restoration.
Unfortunately, the fall of the Tokugawa Shogunate brought with it
a backlash against the Buddhist temples which the Tokugawa's had
made into an arm of their bureaucracy. The new government was determined
to abolish the ideological underpinnings of the Tokugawas and replace
it with their own. This meant the suppression of Buddhism and Neo-Confucianism
and the promotion of Shinto which became the state religion in 1870.
The government destroyed Buddhist temples as part of its violent
anti-Buddhist movement which peaked in 1871. The government even
demanded that Hachiman and Tensho be removed from the Omandalas
of Nichiren Buddhism in their attempts to seperate Buddhism and
Shinto. The anti-Buddhist movement also removed the civil laws against
Buddhist monks and nuns marrying or eating meat in their attempts
to secularize the clergy. They even prohibited the Nichiren Buddhist
practice of marching with drums.
As part of their attempts
to consolidate and thereby control Buddhism, the government was
instrumental in the formation of the modern Japanese Buddhist sects.
In 1876, the Itchi Ha lineages formed the Nichiren Shu. The Shoretsu
Ha lineages became the Myomanji Ha, Komon Ha, Happon Ha, Honjoji
Ha, the Honryuji Ha, and the Fuju Fuse Ha. In 1898, the Myomanji
Ha became the Kempon Hokke Shu, the Happon Ha became the Honmon
Hokke Shu, the Honryuji Ha became the Honmyo Hokke Shu, and the
Honjoji became the Hokke Shu. In 1899, the Komon Ha became the Honmon
Shu. In 1900, Taisekiji became independent from the Honmon Shu and
called itself the Nichiren Shu Fuji Ha. In 1912, they changed their
name again to Nichiren Shoshu. In 1941, the Nichiren Shu, Kempon
Hokke Shu, and Honmon Shu were united, but this only lasted until
after the war.
Arai Nissatsu (1830-1888) was a disciple of Udana-in Nichiki who
became the first superintendent of the Nichiren Shu. In line with
the shoju approach, Nissatsu was a member of the Intersectarian
Cooperative League which formed in 1868 to resist the suppression
of Buddhism by State Shinto. He later helped to form the Society
for Harmony and Respect to promote intersectarian understanding,
and he also helped to found intersectarian welfare projects. Nissatsu
is also said to have taught a revisionist version of Nichiren's
Four Admonitions which reads: "Because we contemplate the Buddha,
ceaselessly devils are quieted; because our words are true, traitors
who would destroy the nation are subdued."
The
Fuji Lineage
The history of the Fuji Lineage
of Nikko is a convoluted story all on its own. It is an important
one, however, because the Nichiren Shoshu sect derives from this
lineage, and through its one-time lay organization, the Soka Gakkai,
the Nichiren Shoshu teachings have spread more widely inside and
outside of Japan than any of the other Nichiren sects. Because of
this, the idiosyncratic views of Nichiren Shoshu are the only ones
commonly known outside Japan, though the major Nichiren schools
in Japan view them as misreprentations of the teachings of Shakyamuni
Buddha and Nichiren Shonin. A careful examination of the history
and claims of Nichiren Shoshu reveal that these teachings are, in
fact, based upon a tapestry of unsubstantiated claims. These idiosyncratic
views cannot be traced back to Nikko himself, but one must understand
the history of Nikko's Lineage and especially the history of Taisekiji
Temple to see how Nichiren Shoshu developed.
To recap, in 1290, the Lord
of Ueno, Nanjo Tokimtsu, built the Taisekiji Temple at Oishigahara
for Nikko who had left Mt. Minobu because of his disputes with Lord
Hakii and Niko. Nanjo Tokimitsu, the Lord of Ueno, was the uncle
of Nikko's disciple Nichimoku.
In 1291, Nikko moved to the
town of Omosu in Kitayama where he founded the Honmonji Temple in
February 1298 with the help of Nitcho. He spent the rest of his
life at this temple. His lineage is referred to as the Fuji Lineage.
Nikko appointed two sets
of six senior disciples to take over for him after his passing.
The first set consisted of: Nikke, Nichimoku, Nisshu, Nichizen,
Nissen, and Nichijo. They were based at Taisekiji Temple, and Nikko
transferred that temple to Nichimoku (1260-1333). The second set
consisted of: Nichidai, Nitcho, Nichido, Nichimyo, Nichigo, and
Nichijo. They were based at Kitayama Honmonji, and Nikko transferred
that temple to Nichidai (1294-1394).
Nikko's relationship with
Nissho, Nichiro, and Niko was adversarial. He obviously disapproved
of Niko's lax standards and resented being forced to leave Mt. Minobu
in 1289. Though he was sympathetic to the plight of Nissho and Nichiro
in 1284 when they were being persecuted in Kamakura, he ended up
accusing them of betraying Nichiren Shonin by returning to the Tendai
fold. Nichiro even visited Nikko at Kitayama Honmonji in an attempt
at reconciliation, but his attempt failed. After 1298, Nikko had
nothing more to do with Nissho and Nichiro. Of the other two of
the six senior disciples, Nitcho joined Nikko at Kitayama Honmonji
and Nichiji left to spread the Odaimoku overseas and was never heard
from again.
Nichizon (1265-1345) was
a disciple of Nikko, who travelled to Kyoto with Nichimoku and Nichigo
who were also Nikko's disciples. Unfortunately, Nichimoku died on
the way and Nichigo returned to Fuji with his ashes. Nichizon alone
went on to Kyoto. In 1339, he established the Jogyo-in Temple. When
Nichizon passed on the Jogyo-in to his disciple Nichi-in, his other
disciple Nichidai (not Nikko's disciple) left and founded Juhonji
Temple in 1363. Both temples were burned down in 1536 during the
Tenmon Persecution. They were united and rebuilt as Yoboji Temple
in 1548.
After the death of Nikke
(1252-1334), one of the first set of Nikko's disciples, Nanjo Tokimitsu
turned his residence in Shimojo into Myorenji Temple.
When Nichimoku left Taisekji
Temple for Kyoto, he left Nichido (1283-1341) in charge of the temple.
When Nichigo (1272-1353) returned with Nichimoku's ashes he fully
expected to take back control of the temple. This resulted in a
dispute between Nichigo and Nichido, and eventually Nichigo was
forced to leave Taisekiji Temple. He went to Hota where he founded
Myohonji Temple around 1343.
Another dispute arose at
Kitayama Honmonji because the patron of the temple, Ishikawa Sanetada,
wanted to remove Nichidai. He eventually succeeded and replaced
him with Nichimyo. Nichidai went to Nishiyama and founded a new
temple with the name Honmonji in 1343. That temple is known as Nishiyama
Honmonji as opposed to Kitayama Honmonji.
In an attempt to upstage
Kityama Honmonji Temple, the Myohonji Temple founded Kuonji Temple
in the town of Koizumi in the Fuji District in 1406.
At this point there were
five major temples of Nikko's Lineage in the Fuji District: Taisekiji,
Kitayama Honmonji, Nishiyama Honmonji, Koizumi Kuonji, and Shimojo
Myorenji. These five are known collectively as the Five Fuji Temples.
Outside of the Fuji area, there would eventually be three other
important temples of the Fuji Lineage: Yanase Jitsujoji, Hota Myohonji,
and Yoboji in Kyoto (formerly the Jogyo-in and Juhonji Temples).
The distinctive doctrines
that would later characterize the Nichiren Shoshu appeared during
the tenure of Nichiu (1409-1482), the ninth high priest of Taisekiji
Temple. The first development was the teaching of Nichigen (?-1486)
of Nishiyama Honmonji identifying Nichiren Shonin as the Buddha.
This theory appeared in the Gonin-shohasho-kenmon which was written
sometime between 1470-1479. Nichigen and Nichiu were friends and
so it is very likely that Nichiu got the idea that Nichiren Shonin
is the True Buddha from Nichigen.
The second development was
the first mention of the "Two Transfer Documents" in a
work called the Hyaku-gojikka-jo written by Nikkyo (1428-1489?)
at Taisekiji Temple in 1480. Nikkyo was originally a priest at Juhonji,
but he moved to Taisekiji and became Nichiu's disciples. The Two
Transfer Documents are the Ikegami Sojo and the Minobu Sojo. In
these alleged writings of Nichiren, he entrusts the Dharma entirely
to Nikko. The Two Transfer Documents are considered to be forgeries
by the other Nichiren Buddhist schools as well as independent scholars
and there are inconsistencies between them, in terms of their content
and Taisekiji claims, and in terms of the actual situation at the
time of Nichiren Shonin's death.
Finally, it was during Nichiu's time as high priest of Taisekiji
that the Daigohonzon first appeared there. Nichijo (d.1493) a contemporary
of Nichiu and the head priest of Kitayama Honmonji actually accused
Nichiu of forging the Ita-mandara (the Daigohonzon) as well as many
other writings. As with the Transfer Documents, there are many reasons
why the Ita-mandara is not considered an authentic Nichiren mandala
outside of the Nichiren Shoshu and their erstwhile lay organization
the Soka Gakkai.
It should be pointed out
that the other temples of the Fuji lineage did not go along with
the doctrinal innovations of Taisekiji. The Yoboji, for example,
signed the Kansho Accord of 1466 along with the other Kyoto temples
without saying a word about the distinctive doctrines of Taisekiji.
It is worth noting that the high priests of Taisekiji Temple from
1617-1707 all came from Yoboji Temple. So it is doubtful if even
all of the high priests of Taisekiji believed in the theory of Nichiren
as the True Buddha, the Daigohonzon, and the transfer documents.
The Ita-mandara itself was kept in storage until the Meiji Restoration.
Nichikan (1665-1726) was
the 26th high priest of Taisekiji Temple and he is considered to
be the one who consolidated and systematized the distinct doctrines
of Nichiren Shoshu, especially the doctrine that Nichiren Shonin
is the Eternal Buddha, not Shakyamuni Buddha. It is Nichikan who
reclaimed Taisekiji from Yoboji and is responsible for restoring
and developing the disctintive doctrines of Taisekiji which first
appeared during the time of Nichiu.
In 1874, Taisekiji Temple
became part of the Shoretsu Branch of Nichiren Buddhism by the decree
of the new Meiji government. In 1876, the eight major temples of
the Nikko Lineage seperated from the other Shoretsu Sects and became
the Komon-ha. In 1899, the Komon-ha became the Honmon Shu. In 1900,
Taisekiji Temple seperated from the Honmon Shu and took the name
Nichiren Shu Fuji-ha. In 1912, it finally took the name Nichiren
Shoshu. The Honmon Shu became a part of Nichiren Shu in 1941. In
1950, the Yoboji Temple seceded from Nichiren Shu and became Nichiren
Honshu. Nishiyama Honmonji also went independent. Shimojo Myorenji
and Hota Myohonji joined Nichiren Shoshu. Kitayama Honmonji, Koizumi
Kuonji, and Yanase Jitsujoji temples all remained with Nichiren
Shu.
---download
click here ---
|